Recap: Agents of S.H.I.E.L.D. – “What They Become”

Skye and her father, "What They Become"

The pieces were all in position, the stakes were set, and the drama had reached a fever pitch.  Everything was ready for a dramatic showdown in the midseason finale, and that’s just what we got.  The rules have been changed, and going forward nothing will be the same.  Characters died, mysteries were solved, new questions were asked, and things set off in entirely new directions for the rest of the season.  In short, this was a big, exciting, important episode for SHIELD, one that delivered on the promise of season two thus far in almost every way imaginable.  So without any further ado, let’s find out “What They Become”, written by Jeffrey Bell and directed by Michael Zinberg.

This week’s thrilling episode picked up right where things left off last week.  Ward, Skye, and Raina board their quinjet and detach from the Bus, as the squad of HYDRA aircraft circles back around for the kill on Agent 33’s orders.  May orders Trip to the cockpit to find them some cloud cover, but she won’t let the Koenigs activate the cloak yet.  She tells them to grab a seat and lock in, because it’s going to get bumpy.  Joining Trip in the cockpit she learns that the nearest cloud cover is 20,000 feet below them.  The Koenigs and Hunter fight over seats while May slams on the breaks, bringing the Bus to a stop in midair, before sending it diving straight down towards the clouds, pursued by HYDRA quinjets.  They get a missile lock on the Bus just as it enters the clouds, and they fire.  As the missiles approach, May launches some ejector seats/escape pods out the side of the Bus (does it not have any chaff?), and activates the cloak.  The missiles hit the escape pods and explode while the Bus glides unseen to safety, fooling the HYDRA pilots.  “Woo!” Trip says, “the word for that kind of flying is ‘fancy’!”  She tells him to head for Puerto Rico while she calls Coulson to let him know that HYDRA has Skye.

They land next to the SHIELD quinjet just as Coulson, Bobbi, and FitzSimmons are returning from the city without Mack.  He tasks FitzSimmons with finding a way to safely get down before talking with May.  She tells him that Ward’s orders from Whitehall were to get Raina, but that he either called an audible when he saw Skye or he has his own agenda.  She says he mentioned something to her about keeping his promise, which Coulson thinks means he’s taking her to meet “daddy dearest.”  He tells Bobbi to check on her contact, Diego, to make sure that he doesn’t tell HYDRA, who are definitely on their way, anything about the entrance to the city.  She looks like she’s going to object, but he tells her they’ll do everything possible to rescue Mack, but the most important thing is to stop HYDRA.

Trip has been digging through his old Howling Commandos box and has found four mechanical detonators from 19145.  Koenig would rather have 10, but they need all they can get since electronics don’t function down in the city.  He tells Trip that Dum Dum Dugan would be proud, but the design of the detonators means they can’t trigger the bombs remotely, so they’ll have to set the timers and run.  They’ll set four charges around the city which should destroy it.  Simmons thinks she’s found a way for them to safely move around in the city, but she’s more concerned with saving Mack.  Fitz tells her that she doesn’t have to act like Mack’s still alive just because he was Fitz’s friend, but she genuinely thinks he might be.  She says that Mack might have been hijacked by the city as a defense mechanism, using him to protect it and treating him like a zombie.  Given the way the Diviner reacts to being touched, it makes sense that the city would have some self-defense.  She insists that there are many possibilities other than Mack being dead, and if he’s still alive then there’s hope that he can be saved.

Bobbi, meanwhile, is in the garage going through Mack’s stuff.  She finds a flash drive just as Hunter walks in asking what she’s looking for.  She passes it off as cleaning for Mack, as he wouldn’t want to see his garage in disarray, going on to say that she knows it’s her fault that Mack’s dead.  Hunter says that no one is saying that, and that heard it wasn’t Mack who came out of the hole.  He tells her she did what need to be done, but wonders why she thinks he’s dead.  She says between whatever infected him and the hundred foot drop he must be dead, and “when this is all over I’m gonna cry for like a week.”  Hunter tells her to come to him, and he gives her a big, comforting hug.  She’s surprised at first but after a moment she gives into it.  He tells her that Mack is one of the best, and if he really is dead then the number of people he trusts on the planet just plummeted.  She says that she thought he didn’t trust anyone, and he says he misspoke and that there are just some people he mistrusts less than others.  Bobbi says she could use some backup, and Hunter wryly replies that he knows a guy and asks if she wants him to check if he’s available.  “Is he good?” she asks, coyly.  “Good enough to know you’re keeping a thumb drive from him,” he says.  He tells her he wants to trust her but it doesn’t seem like he does just yet.

May and Coulson sit together, lamenting the fact that Skye was taken.  He tells her she made the right call, but she thinks she should have put a couple of bullets in Ward’s head.  Coulson reminds her that then they would have blown the Bus out of the sky.  Six SHIELD members are alive because of what she did.  He says she transformed Skye into an agent who is smart, tough and capable.  As Ward leads Skye down a hallway he notices the same thing, how she’s checking the HYDRA agents, weapons, and exits forming a strategy.  He asks Skye how her marksmanship is coming along and she tells him to give her a gun and he’ll find out.  Ward admires her restraint, and she tells him she’s learned control, while HYDRA is only interested in controlling everyone else.  He says he’s not loyal to HYDRA, but she reminds him that they played the game of “let’s kidnap Skye” before and it didn’t end well.  Ward isn’t concerned about that, he only wants to keep his promise.  He opens a door and she finds herself face to face with her father, who is standing waiting for her.  “I’m sure you two have a lot of catching up to do,” Ward says, leaving them alone and closing the door behind him.

Skye’s father watches her, and after staring for a moment tells her that the way she tilts her head is just like her mother, wondering abstractedly about the effects of nature vs nurture.  He gets a little choked up and says he’d promised himself he wouldn’t get emotional, it’s just that he’s waited so long for this moment.  He takes a deep breath, determined to try again, and says, “Hi, I’m Cal.  I’m your father.  Would you like to sit down?”  Skye just shakes her head and he says he doesn’t want to sit either.  He thanks her for meeting with him, and it’s then that she loses it.  “Are you serious?” she asks.  “I was kidnapped off a plane at gunpoint!”  He apologizes, asking that they not lose their heads, and admits that he’s a little nervous.  It’s a big moment, a father-daughter family reunion.  He had plans, including little almond cookies and maybe flowers, but he didn’t want things to go like this or to be here.  “My god, you are beautiful,” he says, distracted.  He says he’s not sure what she knows about him, and she pipes up with the answer.  “You’re a monster, a murderer, there’s a trail of death wherever you go.”  “Those are all true,” he says, “but you need to understand that my little girl… you… were taken from me and my world fell apart.  It was the worst day of my life losing you, but I didn’t lose you.  I wasn’t careless and I didn’t forget you were stolen from me.  I wasn’t always like this.  I wasn’t always a…”

He can’t seem to call himself a monster, so he starts from the beginning.  He tells her that she was born in China, her mother was Chinese, and that they were so happy when she was first born.  He worked at a clinic, people liked him and he liked himself.  He trails off until Skye interrupts him angrily and asks what happened.  “This is the thing I want to say,” Cal says, “I’m sorry I couldn’t be there for you, that I couldn’t protect you, that I couldn’t teach you about the stars or sing you to sleep.  I know I’m a terrible disappointment but I’m here now, and everything that’s about to happen is supposed to happen.”  He says he’s going to take care of her, but she tells him if he wants to do that he should get her out of there.  “Oh, maybe I haven’t been clear,” he says.  “You’re exactly where you’re supposed to be.  This is your destiny.

Bobbi and Hunter have gone to spy on her contact, Diego, who is early to his meeting and is wearing a suit, two things that mean nothing to Hunter but tell Bobbi that something’s wrong.  Two HYDRA agents walk up and shake his hand, and she debates whether he has sold out SHIELD or is playing HYDRA.  The three men walk towards Bobbi and Hunter, who have to decide whether to attack or not.  At the last moment, she turns towards him and starts kissing him just as the men walk by, once they’re gone she finds a note that Diego dropped giving them an address in San Juan.

“You can’t say you’re sorry or that losing me ruined your life,” Skye tells Cal, “and then kidnap me and say that my destiny is to be with you and team HYDRA!”  She opens the door but is met by two HYDRA guards.  She tells her father to tell them to get out of the way, but he closes the door, telling the guards it’s just a little misunderstanding.  He tells her that after today nothing that’s happened will matter, but she says of course they matter.  “You work for Whitehall and HYDRA.  They’re the bad guys and that makes you a bad guy.”  He says he doesn’t work for them, but he needed them to find her and put the pieces together.  He tells her it’s not her fault, and then sets about answering her questions about her mother.  He says she was special, and though that word is used a lot in this case it means she had a gift.  She came from a long line of people with gifts, and Skye has one too and was brought there to receive it.  It’s her birthright, and she’ll undergo a transformation to receive it.  He says that Skye’s mother worked at the clinic with him, helping to translate, when one day a group of men came looking for her, calling themselves SHIELD.  He tried to find her but they told him she was dangerous.  He left Skye with people he trusted and tracked her mother to Europe, but by the time he caught up it was too late.  He tells Skye that Whitehall cut her to pieces, taking her organs and blood for himself, and when he finished butchering her he dumped what was left in a ditch like she was garbage.  He says he’s sorry, and then he starts to hum “Bicycle Built for Two” that we heard last week in Skye’s dream.  He puts his hand on her shoulder as she suddenly remembers having heard the song before.  “She used to sing it to you when you were a baby,” he tells her.  A HYDRA agent interrupts, saying Whitehall wants them.  Cal tells Skye that there will be plenty of time to answer her questions later.  But now that Whitehall has served his purpose, “I’m going to kill the man who destroyed my life.  Best day ever.”  He walks out and Skye buries her face in her hands and cries.


5 thoughts on “Recap: Agents of S.H.I.E.L.D. – “What They Become”

  1. Pingback: Instant Reaction: Agents of SHIELD – “What They Become” | Love Pirate's Ship's Log

  2. Definitely the biggest thing I’m looking forward to in March is Skye’s story. There are so many directions this can be taken that all have different results. Jed and Marissa (the creators) have mentioned many questions such as how the team would react or even if Skye knows she has powers that would affect the entire structure of the rest of the season. I personally think that, like you mentioned, the main issue will be Skye focusing on her new powers, but I personally think it would be interesting if the team didn’t know immediately when we return in March. Part of Skye’s character, which was revisited last week, was a fear of abandonment from the people she cares about, so I don’t think that it would be out of character for her to keep something like this that clearly separates her from the team, even if it would only be for about an episode. No one else in there could testify that Skye has abilities but Raina who the team already doesn’t trust.

    Then again, they are moving quickly through plots, so the show will probably touch upon the team’s reactions faster than we think. The team (at least the original team we started with) wouldn’t be quick to distrust her, but I agree that it will be an elephant in the room just like Skye’s betrayal early last season. She’ll probably seek her father out (Kyle Machlachen’s just too good to lose) but I think it’ll require something big happening. Perhaps another casualty or even a team member hurt as a result of her abilities. Either way, I see a time where Skye leaves the team at least to “make things right.” That being said, Mike Peterson would definitely fit in with that phase of her life as both would be dealing with who they are and what they have done. That’s more of wishful thinking, but I would greatly prefer her to be with Mike than her father for her sake.

    I am excited for Agent Carter (though some of the taglines are getting worse). Unlike SHIELD, there will likely be a beginning, middle, and somewhat end to this story which could make for a less complicated plot filled with hidden motives and sketchy actions. I can see your recaps being shorter because of that, and maybe a brief repose from analyzing every line for some deeper implication, but that’ll definitely return in March. Plus, Agent Carter has the chance of ending on a somewhat positive if foreboding ending as it takes place seventy years in the past. The beginnings of SHIELD and the strength and skills of Peggy Carter could lead to exciting adventures and an even more rich canon of the TV universe. I’m still curious if they’ll make any connections between Agent Carter and SHIELD. I feel like there would be, but I’m still in the dark about how that will happen. Marvel is unusually secretive about its storylines, so it could be anything.

    I’ve never had to think about how I watch TV. I think it usually depends on the show. For comedies and reality, I usually look at the show episode by episode, but for things like SHIELD I tend to look at the big picture. I think my greater inclination is to the greater story because I enjoy seeing characters develop from the starting point to the end. Like Skye developing from a hacktivist living in her van to a full-blown superhero agent of SHIELD, the story becomes even better as you see moments of her growth as something she wouldn’t do in the pilot like trust the team. On the other hand, it probably diminishes my ability to judge an episode on its own merits. All I really notice about individual episodes is whether I prefer them which is a very broad category (I liked episode 2.05 of SHIELD more than 2.06).

    Personally, I’m in a show for the overall story and whether or not I like the characters. I sometimes welcome bad things happening (though probably not to the extent of SHIELD) to test their development, but I’m only human. I cried at the season one finale and usually hope against hope that something good will happen at the end (like Skye meeting with Mike Peterson instead of her father). Most of the time, that makes me think that writers usually shouldn’t take into account what fans want all the time because they all have different ideas (after all, some still don’t care for Skye), but there is some attention that needs to given to viewers. After all, no one would be happy if they randomly killed off Agent May, that would make an interesting story, but it would probably tick everyone off.

    What I do personally, though, is keep track of interviews of rumors, so I tend to know things that could and sometimes do happen such as the Daisy Johnson theory. For shows outside SHIELD, it actually gives me more answers, so a good part of the time I’m not too upset by some plot twists. Still, there’s usually that instant that surprises me, but I like to be well-informed on a show, even if there’s not that much to go on. Either way, I’m in a show for the long run usually until it ends.

    Can’t wait to see Agent Carter in action!

    Liked by 1 person

  3. Wow.

    This just gets better.

    Random thoughts…


    May rules.

    What is The Other Thing that Bobbie and Mack discuss???????????????? (checks Marvel wiki, Mockingjay, er… bird …seems to be a superHERO…). Please never give her a bow. I will be too confused.

    My first reaction to “let’s blow up this cool alien city we just found with unheard of tech and powers and things and stuff was …NOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOO!!!!! The archaeology. The knowledge. The…

    …potential for supervillains to end the world as we know it.

    Oh well, bring on the Howling Commandos gear.

    Hunter’s “travel to exotic lands… and kill them” riff is on a T-shirt I was given years ago by a cousin. It’s a pacifist riff on the military (the tagline on the shirt says “join the army…”).

    Blessings on you for doing the plenty of comic book research to keep up the appearance of actually knowing what you’re talking about. I love comics, along with the rest of the sci-fi fantasy genre, but Marvel’s world is so convoluted I can just barely remember the names of all the Avengers.

    Skye, indeed, has shown some Marvelous growth from her beginnings to this episode. I like having her as a mysteriously “original” , if fairly mundane character… then having her grow into a known comic book superpowered hero. I too think the actress has kicked some butt here, she might have been a mere trope, but has gone far beyond that.

    Tripp was indeed a terrific character, a solid guy at a time of instability, the sort of buddy you’d want at your back. This series has had a great cast of temporary characters (villains and heroes) who do not feel temporary.

    All storytelling is interactive in some way. Even if you write a classic like Lord of the Rings with no fannish input, fans will take the story and interpret it according to their own experience and personalities (nevermind the fanfiction and art…). Film and TV require less work on the part of the audience, the visuals (and the information they carry) are there, spelled out for you… but there is still room for interpretation, for “reading the story” in your own way. In any tale, we have characters we identify with, or relate to. What happens to a background character may not affect me in the same way as what happens to a character I identify with, or one I simply like (bah, phooey, so sorry to see Tripp go). I do need to have a character I relate to , or identify with; tales with lead characters who are difficult or unlikable are quite literary, but I simply can’t abide those kinds of stories. For me, villains raise my hackles, I have a strong sense of justice and allowing someone like Whitehall to continue is nearly blasphemous (I would have shot him a few more times than Coulson did), so simply continuing a villain forever to have someone for the heroes to fight makes me boil; there are always more villains coming down the pike. I was quite happy to see Skye nail Ward a few times… so sorry he had protection… still… he has some storylines to play out, I’m sure. So far, SHIELD has done a fine job of constructing a story that makes archetypal sense.

    I have seen a lot of tumblr posts on the subject of fans and writers’ interactions: the “we did it! we saved ___________ !” (Fans saved Star Trek for one more year back in the 60s, it’s old hat). Surely creators of stories pay attention to their audiences, the audience, the fans, is what makes your story happen, without them, you are the author of nothing. However, they can’t get too bound up in writing the story FOR the fans. They must first write a coherent tale, according to their own wisdom, their own professional skill. Of course, you pause to get some feedback from the fans, but, in the end, you have to just write it.


  4. Can’t wait to see what you think about Agent Carter.

    Beyond the usual insights, I’d like to see what you think about how it fits into the larger Marvel universe.


  5. Pingback: Reaction: Agents of SHIELD – “Aftershocks” and “Who You Really Are” | Love Pirate's Ship's Log

Tell me what you think!

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s