With the Academy Awards fast approaching (Sunday night), I figured it was time for me to offer up my opinions, picks, and predictions. Last year I correctly predicted 13 out of the 24 winners, and 6 out of the 8 winners in the major categories (acting, picture, director, and screenwriting). I’m now going to give you my breakdown of the categories. For each category I have my prediction of who will win (the nominees can be found here), and my pick if I could choose from any film eligible, whether nominated or not. So without further ado.
Best Short Film, Live Action:
Prediction: West Bank Story
My Pick: N/A
Best Short Film, Animated:
Prediction: The Little Matchgirl
My Pick: No Time for Nuts
Best Documentary, Short Subjects:
Prediction: Recycled Life
My Pick: N/A
Best Documentary, Features:
Prediction: An Inconvenient Truth
My Pick: An Inconvenient Truth
I was pretty angry that Shut Up & Sing wasn’t nominated. It’s not my pick, but I definitely think it deserves the nomination.
Best Foreign Language Film of the Year:
Prediction: El Labortino del Fauno (from Mexico)
My Pick: El Labortino del Fauno (from Mexico)
Best Animated Feature Film of the Year:
Prediction: Happy Feet
My Pick: Happy Feet
This is a tough call. I think Happy Feet was deeper and therefore got more attention, but it did not get the overwhelmingly good reviews that Cars did. Plus the Academy has a Pixar bias (The Incredibles, Finding Nemo)
Best Achievement in Visual Effects:
Prediction: Pirates of the Caribbean: Dead Man’s Chest
My Pick: Pirates of the Caribbean: Dead Man’s Chest
Best Achievement in Sound Editing:
Prediction: Letters from Iwo Jima
My Pick: Letters from Iwo Jima
Best Achievement in Sound:
Prediction: Dreamgirls
My Pick: Dreamgirls
Best Achievement in Makeup:
Prediction: El Labortino del Fauno
My Pick: El Labortino del Fauno
Best Achievement in Music Written for Motion Pictures, Original Song:
Prediction: “Listen” – Henry Krieger, Scott Cutler, Anne Previn; Dreamgirls
My Pick: “Life is a Highway” – Rascall Flatts; Cars
I definitely don’t understand why three of the nominees are from Dreamgirls, which is not an original musical. I understand “Listen” was an excuse for Beyonce to get to show off in the movie, and the other two are nice, but it just doesn’t make much sense. None of the songs nominated from Dreamgirls made nearly the impression that the original songs did, and nominating them just because they’re from a musical seems lame. Or maybe it’s just an excuse to keep a country group from performing at the Oscars (just kidding).
Best Achievement in Music Written for Motion Pictures, Original Score:
Prediction: Gustavo Santaolalla; Babel
My Pick: Bill Conti; Rocky Balboa
Best Achievement in Costume Design:
Prediction: The Devil Wears Prada
My Pick: A Prairie Home Companion
Best Achievement in Art Direction:
Prediction: Dreamgirls
My Pick: V for Vendetta
Best Achievement in Editing:
Prediction: United 93
My Pick: United 93
Best Achievement in Cinematography:
Prediction: Children of Men
My Pick: The Illusionist
Best Writing, Screenplay Based on Material Previously Published or Produced:
Prediction: Children of Men
My Pick: A Prairie Home Compaion
So at first I was extremely pissed that Borat got a nomination. It’s such trash that to name it among these other outstanding films is insulting and enraging. Then I realized the irony of it. For a movie that claims to be almost completely improvised and claims to show real people giving their real opinions, it has to have had a significant portion pre-scripted (as the testimonials following its release have attested to), which completely undermines its credibility as a revealing faux-documentary which exposes the true views of Americans. Though, I’m probably just reading into this what I want, so I can allow myself to watch an awards show that nominated Borat for anything. But I love irony.
Best Writing, Screenplay Written Directly for the Screen:
Prediction: Little Miss Sunshine
My Pick: Little Miss Sunshine
Best Achievement in Directing:
Prediction: Martin Scorsese; The Departed
My Pick: Robert Altman; A Prairie Home Companion
I’m sure this will be Scorsese’s year. The Departed was well directed in spurts, but overall was lacking. Part of that is due to the script and we can’t completely fault Scorsese for that. However, I don’t think he deserves this unofficial lifetime achievement award. After all, it’s supposed to be the best directing in 2006 and biases shouldn’t come into play. Of the nominees, it should either be Eastwood or Greengrass, both of whom took a story and made it into art of the highest quality. They made people feel more than just shock, fright or revulsion, unlike Scorsese. There is a reason Eastwood already has two awards in this category, and Greengrass took an impossible film and made it spectacular. Even Frears deserves the award over Scorsese, with his subtlety and grace. I’m sorry, but I think even the best Scorsese is overrated, and this isn’t anywhere close to the best Scorsese. Unfortunately, I still think he’ll win.
Best Performance by an Actress in a Supporting Role:
Prediction: Jennifer Hudson; Dreamgirls
My Pick: Jennifer Hudson; Dreamgirls
If you had taken Hudson’s performance of “And I’m Telling You I’m Not Going” and put it in anything else whatsoever, including Borat, she would still deserve the nomination and the win. And the rest of her performance in Dreamgirls is just as phenominal
Best Performance by an Actor in a Supporting Role:
Prediction: Eddie Murphy; Dreamgirls
My Pick: Eddie Murphy; Dreamgirls
Yes, that’s not a mistake. Perennial fat-suit wearing funnyman Eddie Murphy deserves to win for his both flashy and haunting performance in Dreamgirls. Besides the outlandish performances and personality he showed, the heart-wrenching scene where he silently waits for all of his friends to leave the room before shooting up shows why he deserves this award. (And if they ever have a Best Animated Performance award, they will need to go back in time to award it for his role as Donkey in Shrek.)
Best Performance by an Actress in a Leading Role:
Prediction: Helen Mirren; The Queen
My Pick: Helen Mirren; The Queen
Surest bet this year, and the most deserved.
Best Performance by an Actor in a Leading Role:
Prediction: Forest Whitaker; The Last King of Scotland
My Pick: Sylvester Stallone; Rocky Balboa
Of the nominees in this category, the only film I saw was The Pursuit of Happyness. So while it may be unrealistic, Stallone’s performance showed that actors do get better with age, even if it takes 4 movies in a series and 21 years between such wonderful performances.
Best Picture:
Prediction: Little Miss Sunshine
My Pick: A Prairie Home Companion
I’ve made no secret about how I think A Prairie Home Companion was by far the greatest film of 2006. The surprise here is the prediction of Little Miss Sunshine for Best Picture. I know I’m predicting a major upset here, but I have my reasoning. The Departed, despite Scorsese’s predicted win, is just too violent and has a story too overblown and difficult to identify with to be a major contender. The Queen, while wonderful and understated, is too British and doesn’t pack enough punch or resonance in America for voters to mark it down for the win. Babel (which I did not like) has a good premise and some strong performances, but is not so much of a film as a thesis on the interconnectedness of man. It has some major plot holes and just feels too contrived. While this type of film does appeal to the Academy, with its large and ethnically diverse cast and sprawling locations, I just don’t think it is the sort of film that people will remember 20 years down the road. I loved Letters from Iwo Jima and I think it is an immensly deserving film, far, far better than Babel and The Departed, but I was only able to see it less than 24 hours before the awards ceremony which shows its distribution problems. The vast concensus seems to be that it has little chance, because most of the voters have probably not seen it. It is a unique and interesting film, wonderfully shot as only Eastwood is capable of, and beautifully acted. However, I do not think it has much of a chance, which is a shame. So I’m going with Little Miss Sunshine, the dark “independent” comedy that everyone could find a way to identify with. Bitingly funny, warmly touching, and all around enjoyable, it has the emotional punch to make voters think twice before marking their ballot for something bigger and flashier. It was the one film of these five that people seemed to want to see again and again, something that made them feel good, and important, and special. It’s been either 7 or 8 years since a comedy won (depending on whether you consider American Beauty a comedy. I don’t, so I go with Shakespeare in Love from 8 years back) and I think with the world the way it is, another comedy is due.
So, what do you think? Disagree with any of my predictions or picks? Or agree? The Oscars are Sunday, and afterwards I’ll post my score and my thoughts on the event and the awards for those interested. Have a great Oscar Week.